Tony® Award

• Producer -- Musical Play (1963) - Winner
• Best Musical (1963) - Winner
• Director -- Musical Play (1963) - Winner
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1963) - Nominee
• Musical Actress -- Supporting (1963) - Nominee
• Best Featured Actress in a Musical (1963) - Nominee
• Actor -- Musical Star (1963) - Winner
• Best Author of a Musical (1963) - Winner
• Musical Actor -- Supporting (1963) - Winner
• Best Direction Of A Musical (1963) - Winner
• Musical Play (1963) - Winner
• Best Producer of a Musical (1963) - Winner
• Author -- Musical (1963) - Winner
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1963) - Winner
• Musical Actor -- Supporting (1963) - Nominee
• Best Actor in a Musical (1963) - Winner
• Best Actor in a Musical (1972) - Winner
• Supporting Actor In A Musical Play (1972) - Winner
• Actor (Musical) (1972) - Winner
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1972) - Winner
• Director Of A Musical (1972) - Nominee
• Best Direction Of A Musical (1972) - Winner
• Best Revival Of A Musical (1996) - Winner
• Featured Actor In A Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Best Direction Of A Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Actor (Musical) (1996) - Winner
• Best Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Revival Of A Musical: (1996) - Nominee
• Director Of A Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Best Featured Actor in a Musical (1996) - Nominee

Drama Desk Award

• Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical (1991) - Nominee
• Outstanding Revival of a Musical (1996) - Nominee
• Outstanding Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Best Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner

Outer Critics Circle Award

• Best Actor in a Musical (1996) - Winner
• Best Director of a Musical (1996) - Winner